Now that’s a divisive issue. Heat: Melinda’s. Flavor: Trader Joe’s.
Wheniamnotbanned
Trader Joes
Indigenousboy420
Both are great but Trader Joe’s is fucking god tier
zdh989
TJ’s is surprisingly very, very good.
Few_Statistician9873
ET in the back
NativeSceptic1492
The Melinda’s because they’re pretty consistent and easy to find. Trader Joe’s house brand products while they are pretty good too, they are often discontinued without notice. I find it irritating.
boston_nsca
Melinda’s for me. I go through a bottle of ghost pepper a month lol
jadejazzkayla
TJ
BigJim_TheTwins
My Melinda’s infatuation runs deep. Always Melinda’s
Responsible_Cod_5540
Melinda. TJ’s is flavorful, but the heat is mild. Melinda’s know their stuff.
Sauce_Taker100
Melinda’s 4 me
Californial21
Melinda’s
Creamcheese666
Melinda all day
Johnny-Decent
Meli’s probably clears but that TJ ain’t no joke.
Unreal_Idealz
Damn, the two I have in my fridge in addition to my own homemade sauce. They all have their uses and there’s no wrong answer
R2-D2savestheday
I haven’t had Trader Joe’s but I love Melindas, so I’m picking that one
Formal_Progress_2573
TJ all day. I don’t even care about Melinda’s screwing over marie sharp I just think their sauces all have a terrible taste, I think it’s how it’s fermented or something. I have never understood how so many people on this sub love them so much.
jacobryan24
Both in my top 5 but gonna give it to TJs. More flavor
ChawulsBawkley
The shorter, pinker one
otc108
I love both, but for the price and what you’re getting, TJ’s is a fucking deal at $2.99!
Affectionate_ruin508
Trader Joe’s has better flavor IMO.
Crotalus999
TJ’s hands down. Won’t spend a penny on Melinda’s after what went down with Marie Sharp. No quarter for thieves!
MrFritzCSGO
Tjs for sure here, love that sauce
katplasma
Melindas 1000%. not even remotely close
Kooky-Mode4761
Left
darknight9064
The tan one is a little less creepy.
Sun-Much
Melinda’s all day long. They have a Roasted Garlic and Habanero that is my daily driver right now.
Doug-Life80
That one
Saruvan_the_White
TJ’s.
eriec0aster
#TJ’s Superiority
Frosty_Concept_1120
Ghost Pepper
massive_delivery69
I don’t care for any of those hotsauces I only want that ET so I can phone home
Chrsst916
Melindas ghost pepper all day
geebz42
Everybody talkin bout ET and hot sauce, but what about the booty magnet
35 Comments
Now that’s a divisive issue. Heat: Melinda’s. Flavor: Trader Joe’s.
Trader Joes
Both are great but Trader Joe’s is fucking god tier
TJ’s is surprisingly very, very good.
ET in the back
The Melinda’s because they’re pretty consistent and easy to find. Trader Joe’s house brand products while they are pretty good too, they are often discontinued without notice. I find it irritating.
Melinda’s for me. I go through a bottle of ghost pepper a month lol
TJ
My Melinda’s infatuation runs deep. Always Melinda’s
Melinda. TJ’s is flavorful, but the heat is mild. Melinda’s know their stuff.
Melinda’s 4 me
Melinda’s
Melinda all day
Meli’s probably clears but that TJ ain’t no joke.
Damn, the two I have in my fridge in addition to my own homemade sauce. They all have their uses and there’s no wrong answer
I haven’t had Trader Joe’s but I love Melindas, so I’m picking that one
TJ all day. I don’t even care about Melinda’s screwing over marie sharp I just think their sauces all have a terrible taste, I think it’s how it’s fermented or something. I have never understood how so many people on this sub love them so much.
Both in my top 5 but gonna give it to TJs. More flavor
The shorter, pinker one
I love both, but for the price and what you’re getting, TJ’s is a fucking deal at $2.99!
Trader Joe’s has better flavor IMO.
TJ’s hands down. Won’t spend a penny on Melinda’s after what went down with Marie Sharp. No quarter for thieves!
Tjs for sure here, love that sauce
Melindas 1000%. not even remotely close
Left
The tan one is a little less creepy.
Melinda’s all day long. They have a Roasted Garlic and Habanero that is my daily driver right now.
That one
TJ’s.
#TJ’s Superiority
Ghost Pepper
I don’t care for any of those hotsauces I only want that ET so I can phone home
Melindas ghost pepper all day
Everybody talkin bout ET and hot sauce, but what about the booty magnet
Trader Joe’s all truckin day